Skip to content Posts

Blue Door Pub – The Blucy

My apologies for the complete lack of pictures from the actual experience.  My camera batteries are dead and the ones I took on my iPhone did not work out so well. Bad blogger, I know.

The bar/restaurant: The Blue Door Pub, St. Paul

1811 Selby Ave
St. Paul, MN 55104

The first thing of note was that the place is WAY smaller than I’d expected. I guess I didn’t know what to expect, but I’d heard about Buck Hunter and such, so I had pictured a spacious area with lots of seating.

Not so! There were 6 seats at the small bar by the front window, and (hang on while I count ’em)… something like 8-10 tables, 4ish booths, and a bar/barstools by a front window for perching and side-by-side eating.

With no room for a podium for a host, let alone room for a host to really stand in one place, I asked a bartender if we needed to get on a list of any kind. He said, “find the cute redhead and give her your name.”  The cute redhead was easy to spot with such an apt description, so as I glanced around the place, I quickly found her. We put our names on the list and headed towards the bar to wait. Twenty minutes later, we were seated at our table.

Beers: between the two of us, we got a Surly Furious and the Liftbridge Biscotti. I’d recently skimmed a note on MNBeer about it, so when I saw it on the menu it piqued my interest. It’s awesome. MNBeer describes it here as:

“… an array of malts, oats, wheat, pure local honey, light European hops and delicately spicing with Grains of Paradise, Madagascar vanilla beans, whole star anise, all brought together with traditional Belgian yeast, the result is a cloudy, deep copper colored, complex experience.”

After we were seated, we immediately started off with an order of beer-battered green beans (delicious!).  That counts as a veggie serving, right?  Right.

Onto the burgers…

While I was more than tempted by such Juicy offerings as a Pizza Blucy or a Bacon Blucy, I decided to keep it real and opted for their signature burger – The Blucy:

The Blucy – 6.50
Our flagship burger! We stuff bleu cheese and finely chopped garlic into a half pound of Angus beef.

It was amazingly delicious. As, I mentioned on Metblogs, it was perfectly cooked (just a teeeeeny bit pink, right in the middle), flavorfully bleu-cheesy and garlicky and the bun was perfect. When you get to the gooey center you’ve got to REALLY love bleu cheese as that is some intense smelly cheese action, but all in all? Awesome, awesome, awesome.


  • Service: beyond friendly, and they were not a bit flustered by the packed house (though, as the bartender mentioned, that crowd was totally normal for dinnertime).
  • Food: The burgers were impressive.  For Jucy Lucy purists (Hi, Matt’s Bar), their signature is not your “classic” meat+cheese+fried onions offering, but they do make one appropriately titled “The Classic” for those of you that hate idea of anything other than the basics. For putting their own spin on the original, it’s a much better version than Bar Abilene attempted with their Southwest Lucy (not enough cheese, too many toppings).  I want to try all of them, and their other Blucy offerings include Luau, Pizza, Bacon, Breakfast and Cajun.
  • Price: It’s important to note that the burger itself doesn’t come with an included side of fries or other options, but at $6.50 for the burger, it’s tough to complain about a couple bucks to add on some potatoes, or in our case – the beer-battered green beans for $2.75. Fries and tots are $1.75. As for the beers, I found nothing on the tap list that was more than $4.

Overall – I will be back.


The Juicy Lucy Adventure Continues

I’ve been a good girl so far and have eaten more fruits, veggies, fibers and grains this past week than I think I did all of 2008. I feel good, have more energy, and feel a nice little sense of accomplishment for having stuck with a New Year’s Resolution for seven whole days.

For that reason, I didn’t even blink at a recent suggestion to have a Juicy Lucy excursion this weekend.  Besides, a lifestyle without Jucy Lucy burgers is not my idea of healthy. Here’s the plan:

We will continue our quest through the Twin Cities for the Best Juicy Lucy Burger tomorrow night at The Blue Door, St. Paul.

I’ve heard a zillion things about their signature Blucy (appropriately titled The Blucy and stuffed with Bleu Cheese and garlic!), so I think I’m going to try that one . This was a tough decision as two others include bacon and they offer a Pizza Blucy as well. Mmm… bacon.

I’m also totally stoked about the beer-battered green beans that are available with the burgers for a bit of an upcharge ($2.75), but I think it’s going to be worth it.

Pair that with a local brew? I’m sold.

A quick recap of places explored so far:

  • The Nook (St. Paul): I like this one because of the Paul Molitor option (pepper jack instead of American cheese)
  • Matt’s Bar (Minneapolis): The favorite so far; just good, classic, straightforward, unpretentious meat and cheese excellence.
  • The 5-8 Club (Minneapolis): Another straightforward meat-cheese execution
  • Bar Abilene (Uptown): Initially intrigued and excited by their southwestern flavors and styles, this one was ultimately disappointing. Not awesome. Not enough cheese! And way too many toppings.
  • Shamrock’s – This one is pretty much the same as The Nook as far as the burger itself goes, and right up there with deliciousness.