As per usual, Minnesota Public Radio’s The Current in partnership with The Citizen’s League pulled off a sweet Policy and a Pint event last Thursday night (10/8). As much as I enjoyed the UBS Forum at the MPR studios in St. Paul, MN, I heartheartheart the Varsity Theater and was so very excited to see the event back there.
The topic: Education
What makes for a good teacher? What changes do we need to see in teaching to ensure the best futures for our children? How much input should parents have for their children’s education? How much responsibility should they take?
My companion: my beautiful (inside and out), dedicated and passionate first-grade-teacher sister, Miranda
The fun part: The Citizens League asked me to “live-tweet” the event and the MPR crew asked if they could chat with me about it afterwards, which was super fun.
Anyway, you can check out the play-by-play of the event here as @AmySBryant and I essentially #duelingtweeters‘ed, but the highlights (my takeaways) from the event are here:
1. Amber Damm, MN Teacher of the Year, is very fortunate to be able to write her own curriculum in the school where she teaches.Teachers are often required by their districts to nearly follow materials verbatim (I’m assuming this is true in other states too, right?), almost as if there were a script, in the name of continuity and teaching to the standardized tests. Amber is a middle school English teacher that commits each year to different focuses of study including film, history, poetry, novels, music and art.
2. Nate Eklund, professional speaker and trainer and author of How Was Your Day at School? Improving Dialogue About Teacher Job Satisfaction – offered some really, really great perspective as a former teacher and current Education Consultant. He was a confident and articulate speaker and his passion for his involvement in education was apparent.
3. The relationship between teacher and parents has to be one of trust and of humility. There are moments when the parents need to trust that the educator has the best solution/answer to a particular situation, and there are instances when the educator needs to show humility and admit that they don’t know, that the parents DO know best, and then to commit to learning from that situation and growing. This is easier said than done.
We also addressed things like teachers’ salaries, Teach for America, job satisfaction, moving vocational experts into the teaching field, private/charter/public/homeschooling options, and layoffs. We covered a lot of ground in an hour!
As always, Steve Seel proved a great moderator obviously being familiar with the accomplishments, writings, and stances of the speakers as well as directing questions from the crowd to the speakers, and with keeping the momentum going and the event on schedule (for the most part).
On top of all that great info, I made new friends, which is always a win for me. I was so excited to get to meet Mr. Eklund as well as MPR’s Steve Seel (The Current DJ) and Tom Weber (Education Reporter for MPR, who has great, great hair). I love being involved with public radio events and happenings, and If we learned anything from DeRushaDay, it’s that I get absolutely giddy meeting people in the local journo/ad/media scene.
Wait a second – didn’t I JUST POST this week about how I wanted to further my involvement in public media aside from being a member? Yes, yes I did.
Also, being there with Miranda was the BEST part – hearing the thoughts of a real!life!teacher! post-discussion about education and teachers in Minnesota just brought it all home. We headed next door to the (same owners) Loring Pasta Bar for, well, pasta, another glass of wine and a recap of the evening. From an informative standpoint, it was lovely to get her thoughts on the issues that were addressed. From a personal standpoint, it brings me SUCH great joy to watch her eyes light up as she shares her thoughts on a topic so personal to her and that she dedicates so much of her passionate energy to.
~ * ~ * ~ * ~ * ~ * ~
My best impressions of great teachers are always the ones that spent the time needed to answer the further questions you had, the ones that motivated and encouraged learning to continue outside the classrooms, and the ones that were so passionate about their jobs and their subject material that it was impossible not to get on board.
This event got me thinking about teachers that made a lasting impression on me. These are them:
Park High School’s Mr. Bach (Honors Chem) for teaching me that I can, in fact grasp chemical properties and reactions even if I’d rather be writing, Mr. Hyland (Social Studies) for teaching with a sense of humor, and Mr. Detviler (Political Science) for prioritizing relationships with EACH of his students; and to the University of Minnesota’s School of Journalism and Mass Communication’s Mr. John Rash (who would later serve as one of my most influential mentors and bosses), THANK YOU.
Also? To my parents, who sacrificed all sorts of things to teach Miranda and I from home for over five years, for instilling in us both not only the desire to constantly be learning, but the ability to process information and essentially, teach ourselves.
For being great teachers and inspiring me to the degree that 5, 7, and 10 years later you’re the ones that come to mind when someone asks about “great teachers,” I’ve had before.
I know some of you readers are teachers and lots of you folks are Minnesotans – any thoughts on teaching in your city/state/school and how you’d improve it? Those that are further removed from the teaching profession – what do you remember about the most influential teachers you had through school?
Doniree Walker is an aspiring yogini, jet-setter, foodie, and story-teller. She's a writer and geek girl by trade, and a lover and a connector by lifestyle, and is currently obsessed with: train travel, single-serving chocolate milk, and brand new notebooks. Oh, and she's also part supergirl. Wanna be friends? 






{ 28 comments… read them below or add one }
Sometimes I think about being a teacher. I thought about it a lot during my five years at camp, but I just don't know that I'd be able to do it justice.
You'd make an excellent teacher, honey. I mean, you already are a summer
teacher for those kids – you'd be phenomenal. And the fact that you're not
sure if you'd “do it justice”? Makes me believe you would and then some.
I wish we had something like this in Sacramento—I'd be all about it. As a teacher myself (8th grade English, baby!) I love it that your city is making people aware/getting people talking about all the issues that face education today—there are a lot. Also, great job mentioning your favorite teachers—there really is nothing better than a former student telling you that you made a difference.
I think the best teachers are the ones who show they care about you as a student as well as a human being. My favorite teacher was Mr. Cooley. Not only b/c he was good looking (haha) but also because you could tell he genuinely cared for every single one of his students and took the time to get to know them and teach them.
Sometimes I think about being a teacher. I thought about it a lot during my five years at camp, but I just don't know that I'd be able to do it justice.
You'd make an excellent teacher, honey. I mean, you already are a summer
teacher for those kids – you'd be phenomenal. And the fact that you're not
sure if you'd “do it justice”? Makes me believe you would and then some.
I wish we had something like this in Sacramento—I'd be all about it. As a teacher myself (8th grade English, baby!) I love it that your city is making people aware/getting people talking about all the issues that face education today—there are a lot. Also, great job mentioning your favorite teachers—there really is nothing better than a former student telling you that you made a difference.
I commented at my own blog, knowing it would get long.
http://dreamstela.wordpress.com/2009/10/12/649/
I toy with the idea of moonlighting as a programming teacher somewhere, where I'd have enough latitude to teach them not only to solve the problems their given, but to solve problems that are less well-defined and to think outside the proverbial box.
Programming (and computer science, in general) has greatly expanded my ability to solve problems through critical thinking and patient, methodical analysis of the problem being solved. It's something that I find absent in far too many young people.
This absence of self-guided problem solving has a couple of root causes, IMO:
1. The standard curriculum at public schools these days is utter crap.
2. Parents and educators have apparently abandoned useful learning tools, such as the Socratic and Scientific Methods, instead rewarding the urge for instant gratification.
3. Google and Wikipedia are a lot easier to use than their dead-tree counterparts, so no one learns to use a card catalog or scan a book's index anymore.
I think the best teachers are the ones who show they care about you as a student as well as a human being. My favorite teacher was Mr. Cooley. Not only b/c he was good looking (haha) but also because you could tell he genuinely cared for every single one of his students and took the time to get to know them and teach them.
I commented at my own blog, knowing it would get long.
http://dreamstela.wordpress.com/2009/10/12/649/
I agree with what kellie said. The best teachers care about the student inside and outside of the classroom. I had a 3rd grade teacher, Mrs. Miller, and a 7th grade teacher, Mrs. Geene, who both cared SO MUCH about their students.
And I do feel sorry for kids who are forced to have teachers who are not really “there” (interaction wise) and are just trying to get the kids up to speed enough for the next grade.
I toy with the idea of moonlighting as a programming teacher somewhere, where I'd have enough latitude to teach them not only to solve the problems their given, but to solve problems that are less well-defined and to think outside the proverbial box.
Programming (and computer science, in general) has greatly expanded my ability to solve problems through critical thinking and patient, methodical analysis of the problem being solved. It's something that I find absent in far too many young people.
This absence of self-guided problem solving has a couple of root causes, IMO:
1. The standard curriculum at public schools these days is utter crap.
2. Parents and educators have apparently abandoned useful learning tools, such as the Socratic and Scientific Methods, instead rewarding the urge for instant gratification.
3. Google and Wikipedia are a lot easier to use than their dead-tree counterparts, so no one learns to use a card catalog or scan a book's index anymore.
I agree with what kellie said. The best teachers care about the student inside and outside of the classroom. I had a 3rd grade teacher, Mrs. Miller, and a 7th grade teacher, Mrs. Geene, who both cared SO MUCH about their students.
And I do feel sorry for kids who are forced to have teachers who are not really “there” (interaction wise) and are just trying to get the kids up to speed enough for the next grade.
oh… they learn all these tools in grad school because they have to… but that is why everyone isn't running around with a REAL PhD or MS or MA or BFA or something.
by REAL I mean not an online degree like from Phoenix.
you should go to grad school, then you'll feel right at home. seriously. you would probably enjoy it much more than undergrad even if it is a lot of work.
all these replies are great! see mine here: http://tinyurl.com/yjp8fw4
I think one of the biggest things that can be done to improve the teaching profession AND the state of education in this country is to move to performance-based pay. Currently, teachers get raises for years of service and for the amount of education. This means that an excellent teacher and a a terrible teacher can make the same amount of money if they both have the same education and years of experience. What's that about?
Teaching is an amazing profession and an awesome responsibility. It's time for this country to start giving good teachers the professional recognition they deserve.
“My best impressions of great teachers are always the ones that spent the time needed to answer the further questions you had, the ones that motivated and encouraged learning to continue outside the classrooms, and the ones that were so passionate about their jobs and their subject material that it was impossible not to get on board.”
I cannot concur more. To that, I extremely miss teaching. As difficult and tiring as it was, it was worth every moment.
>> http://phampants.wordpress.com/2008/01/21/heart...
oh… they learn all these tools in grad school because they have to… but that is why everyone isn't running around with a REAL PhD or MS or MA.
you should go to grad school, then you'll feel right at home.
all these replies are great! see mine here: http://tinyurl.com/yjp8fw4
I think one of the biggest things that can be done to improve the teaching profession AND the state of education in this country is to move to performance-based pay. Currently, teachers get raises for years of service and for the amount of education. This means that an excellent teacher and a a terrible teacher can make the same amount of money if they both have the same education and years of experience. What's that about?
Teaching is an amazing profession and an awesome responsibility. It's time for this country to start giving good teachers the professional recognition they deserve.
“My best impressions of great teachers are always the ones that spent the time needed to answer the further questions you had, the ones that motivated and encouraged learning to continue outside the classrooms, and the ones that were so passionate about their jobs and their subject material that it was impossible not to get on board.”
I cannot concur more. To that, I extremely miss teaching. As difficult and tiring as it was, it was worth every moment.
>> http://phampants.wordpress.com/2008/01/21/heart...
This makes me wish that I knew more about your education system! =) You have all kinds of fun stuff going on down there, I'm jealous!
This makes me wish that I knew more about your education system! =) You have all kinds of fun stuff going on down there, I'm jealous!
I agree with #1 & #3. #2 uses words that are too big for me.
Good teachers can skirt around #1's problems. And can you believe everything that is posted on Wiki?
Doniree, you and Miranda were model students, and a pleasure to teach!
I agree with #1 & #3. #2 uses words that are too big for me.
Good teachers can skirt around #1's problems. And can you believe everything that is posted on Wiki?
Doniree, you and Miranda were model students, and a pleasure to teach!